The Lantern Media Group

Serving the Carolinas and beyond follow us for the history and mysteries but stick around for the inside scoop on the destinations, food and dining, and attractions.

Follow Me

The First Unsolved Mystery Case in America Occurred in North Carolina: Virginia Dare

North Carolina is home to America’s first mystery, when the first attempted English settlement vanished on Roanoke Island. Virginia Dare, the firstborn English child in the new colony, disappeared by 1590, sparking controversy about her fate. Some believe she lived among the natives, where she encountered a witch doctor who wished to marry her. After her refusal, he put Virginia under a spell, turning her into a ghostly white doe that can still be seen today. The White Doe Inn Bed and Breakfast upholds the lore in downtown Manteo.

Written By: John G. Clark Jr.
Image By: John G. Clark Jr.
Source: NCpedia
(Note) The legend says a sly old witch doctor, not a medicine man. Many have speculated about what happened to the lost colony and the fate of Virginia Dare.